Change Your Game & Change Your Life
WD PoweredAI · Trade Analyzer · Week 11

James Cook III for Tyler Shough: Who Wins This Trade?

Updated November 22, 2026 · Rest-of-season PPR values from the WinDaily model

RB · BillsQB · SaintsRest of season
Edge: James Cook IIIJames Cook III is worth about 89% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR).

Side by side

James Cook IIITyler Shough
Position · teamRB · BillsQB · Saints
PPR points per game20.416.3
Rest-of-season PPR pts142113
Points above replacement (rest of season)71-5
Half-PPR rest of season126115
Bye week78
Remaining scheduleaverageaverage
Injury statusHealthyHealthy

WD PoweredAI verdict

Decline

This is a lopsided trade in your favor to decline. You're giving up a premier RB1 with 71.3 points of value over replacement for a QB with negative replacement value.

  • James Cook is producing 20.4 PPR points per game with seven games remaining for 141.6 total points. His 71.3-point value over replacement is elite—that's a first-round caliber player. Tyler Shough, while getting significant volume at QB, projects to 16.3 PPR points per game and carries -4.6 replacement value, meaning he's actually underperforming what you'd expect from a waiver-wire QB.
  • The math here is stark: you're trading 82.6 total value for 9.1 value received. Even in PPR scoring where WRs and pass-catchers benefit, trading a lead RB for any QB is almost never mathematically sound. The positional scarcity gap between elite RBs and replaceable QBs makes this especially painful.
  • You should have no trouble finding a competent QB on waivers or through a much cheaper trade. Cook's remaining schedule is average but his volume and production are well above water. Hold this asset.

If Cook suffers a sudden injury or if Shough puts up 25+ PPR points for two straight weeks, the calculus shifts, but nothing in the current data suggests those scenarios are imminent.

Verdict assumes you give James Cook III and get Tyler Shough, PPR scoring.

Related trades

Play your new lineup: fantasy app offers

18+ (21+ in some states) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

Should I trade James Cook III for Tyler Shough?

James Cook III is worth about 89% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR). James Cook III projects for 131 PPR points the rest of the season and Tyler Shough for 115.

Who has more fantasy value rest of season, James Cook III or Tyler Shough?

James Cook III (131 PPR points) over Tyler Shough (115).

Fantasy app promo codes: PrizePicks promo code · Underdog promo code · Sleeper promo code · DraftKings Pick6 promo code · Betr Picks promo code. New-player offers checked November 2026; availability depends on your state.