Change Your Game & Change Your Life
WD PoweredAI · Trade Analyzer · Week 11

Caleb Williams for James Cook III: Who Wins This Trade?

Updated November 22, 2026 · Rest-of-season PPR values from the WinDaily model

QB · BearsRB · BillsRest of season
Edge: James Cook IIIJames Cook III is worth about 58% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR).

Side by side

Caleb WilliamsJames Cook III
Position · teamQB · BearsRB · Bills
PPR points per game20.420.4
Rest-of-season PPR pts141142
Points above replacement (rest of season)2471
Half-PPR rest of season142126
Bye week107
Remaining scheduleaverageaverage
Injury statusHealthyHealthy

WD PoweredAI verdict

Accept

Accept this trade decisively. You're upgrading from a QB to an elite RB with virtually identical rest-of-season scoring but dramatically higher positional value.

  • On raw points, Caleb Williams and James Cook are nearly identical: both project 140+ points over your final 7 games with matching 20.4 PPR points per game. The critical difference is positional scarcity. Cook's 71.3 value over replacement means he's 71 points ahead of a league-average RB; Williams is only 23.5 points ahead of a replacement QB. That 48-point gap in scarcity is what makes this lopsided.
  • You're also solving a roster math problem. QB is the easiest position to stream and find depth; running back is not. By converting your QB into an elite RB, you're addressing your most scarce asset position. Williams can be replaced by waiver-wire options or mid-tier streaming QBs without meaningful loss. Cook cannot.
  • Cook's bye week 7 is already past (we're at week 11), so you gain a roster spot advantage immediately with no future bye concerns. The schedule strength is equivalent for both players, so no edge there.

Cook's workload could diminish if the Bills' offense shifts, but as long as he's the primary back, this remains a clear win for the elite RB upside over positional depth at QB.

Verdict assumes you give Caleb Williams and get James Cook III, PPR scoring.

Related trades

Play your new lineup: fantasy app offers

18+ (21+ in some states) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

Should I trade Caleb Williams for James Cook III?

James Cook III is worth about 58% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR). Caleb Williams projects for 142 PPR points the rest of the season and James Cook III for 131.

Who has more fantasy value rest of season, Caleb Williams or James Cook III?

James Cook III (142 PPR points) over Caleb Williams (131).

Fantasy app promo codes: PrizePicks promo code · Underdog promo code · Sleeper promo code · DraftKings Pick6 promo code · Betr Picks promo code. New-player offers checked November 2026; availability depends on your state.