Change Your Game & Change Your Life
WD PoweredAI · Trade Analyzer · Week 11

James Cook III for Patrick Mahomes: Who Wins This Trade?

Updated November 22, 2026 · Rest-of-season PPR values from the WinDaily model

RB · BillsQB · ChiefsRest of season
Edge: James Cook IIIJames Cook III is worth about 41% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR).

Side by side

James Cook IIIPatrick Mahomes
Position · teamRB · BillsQB · Chiefs
PPR points per game20.422.2
Rest-of-season PPR pts142156
Points above replacement (rest of season)7136
Half-PPR rest of season126144
Bye week75
Remaining scheduleaverageaverage
Injury statusHealthyHealthy

WD PoweredAI verdict

Decline

You're being asked to trade a premier running back for a quarterback, and the model strongly favors keeping James Cook. The gap in value is significant enough that you should decline this offer.

  • James Cook projects to 141.6 PPR points over the final 7 weeks—elite production for a running back. His value over replacement (71.3 points) is exceptionally high because quality RB options are scarce. Patrick Mahomes will score more total points (155.8), but that's because quarterback scoring is inflated; his value over a replacement-level QB is only 36.3 points.
  • In PPR scoring, running backs who catch passes like Cook are especially valuable, and the Bills offense remains dynamic. Meanwhile, taking on Mahomes means you're using roster flexibility and an early draft pick on a position where the drop-off to streaming alternatives is much gentler than at RB. If your QB situation is dire, the math changes—but the model assumes normal roster depth.
  • Cook's bye (week 7) is already in the rearview mirror at week 11, eliminating future bye concerns. Mahomes' upcoming bye in week 5 is minimal impact at this point. The fundamental problem: you're surrendering a rare, high-upside skill-position asset for a position where the weekly variance between QB1 and QB15 is smaller.

If your current QB is injured or truly unplayable and you have another quality RB on your bench, the calculus shifts—but as presented, this favors declining.

Verdict assumes you give James Cook III and get Patrick Mahomes, PPR scoring.

Related trades

Play your new lineup: fantasy app offers

18+ (21+ in some states) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

Should I trade James Cook III for Patrick Mahomes?

James Cook III is worth about 41% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR). James Cook III projects for 131 PPR points the rest of the season and Patrick Mahomes for 144.

Who has more fantasy value rest of season, James Cook III or Patrick Mahomes?

James Cook III (144 PPR points) over Patrick Mahomes (131).

Fantasy app promo codes: PrizePicks promo code · Underdog promo code · Sleeper promo code · DraftKings Pick6 promo code · Betr Picks promo code. New-player offers checked November 2026; availability depends on your state.