Change Your Game & Change Your Life
WD PoweredAI · Trade Analyzer · Week 11

Caleb Williams for Christian McCaffrey: Who Wins This Trade?

Updated November 22, 2026 · Rest-of-season PPR values from the WinDaily model

QB · BearsRB · 49ersRest of season
Edge: Christian McCaffreyChristian McCaffrey is worth about 60% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR).

Side by side

Caleb WilliamsChristian McCaffrey
Position · teamQB · BearsRB · 49ers
PPR points per game20.421.7
Rest-of-season PPR pts141143
Points above replacement (rest of season)2477
Half-PPR rest of season142129
Bye week108
Remaining scheduleaveragetough
Injury statusHealthyHealthy

WD PoweredAI verdict

Accept

This is a lopsided trade in your favor. You're acquiring Christian McCaffrey, one of the league's most valuable players, in exchange for a solid QB1—a significant upgrade at a premium position.

  • McCaffrey projects to 143.2 points over your remaining 7 games compared to Williams' 140.8, so you're gaining minimal PPR production. But the real story is positional scarcity: McCaffrey carries 76.6 points of value over replacement-level RB play, while Williams only provides 23.5 points over replacement-level QB play. That's a 53-point gap in positional advantage.
  • You're paying 34.8 value points to receive 88.1—a 2.5x return on investment. The model heavily rewards you for moving from a replaceable position (QB has streaming depth) to a scarce one (elite RBs are rare). Yes, McCaffrey's schedule is tougher and his bye is imminent (week 8), but his ceiling at the position justifies the trade.
  • The only math concern: you're giving 1 player for 1 player, so roster impact is neutral. This hinges entirely on positional value, where you're winning decisively.

If McCaffrey's workload decreases due to injury or the 49ers' game scripts shift dramatically, the gap narrows—but his baseline role is too valuable to expect significant decline.

Verdict assumes you give Caleb Williams and get Christian McCaffrey, PPR scoring.

Related trades

Play your new lineup: fantasy app offers

18+ (21+ in some states) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

FAQ

Should I trade Caleb Williams for Christian McCaffrey?

Christian McCaffrey is worth about 60% more in trade value (points above a waiver-wire replacement, PPR). Caleb Williams projects for 142 PPR points the rest of the season and Christian McCaffrey for 143.

Who has more fantasy value rest of season, Caleb Williams or Christian McCaffrey?

Christian McCaffrey (143 PPR points) over Caleb Williams (142).

Fantasy app promo codes: PrizePicks promo code · Underdog promo code · Sleeper promo code · DraftKings Pick6 promo code · Betr Picks promo code. New-player offers checked November 2026; availability depends on your state.