NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year Odds: Mendoza Still Leads Kalshi After First Start

NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year Odds: Mendoza Still Leads Kalshi After First Start

Updated November 20, 2026

Kalshi · New Users

Kalshi: Trade $25, Get a $55 Bonus

Sign up for Kalshi through Win Daily (referral code DAILYPLAYS applies automatically) and trade $25 to get a $55 bonus.

CLAIM THE $55 KALSHI BONUSKALSHI REVIEW

18+ (21+ where required). New users only. Terms apply. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange; event contract trading involves significant risk. Not available in all jurisdictions; sports contracts are unavailable in some states. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Fernando Mendoza is still the favorite in the NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year odds on Kalshi, priced at 25% as of about 11:35 AM ET on Nov. 20, 2026, up from 21% before his first NFL start. Broncos running back Jonah Coleman (19%) and Titans receiver Carnell Tate (15%) are next, while Browns receiver Denzel Boston has slipped to 10%.

Here is where the race stands, what Mendoza’s debut against Seattle did to the market, the games that can move it next, and how to trade it on Kalshi.

Offensive Rookie of the Year odds on Kalshi right now

Kalshi’s AP Offensive Rookie of the Year market has traded about $8.6 million. Each contract pays $1 if that player wins the award, so a price of 25¢ works out to roughly a 25% chance.

PlayerTeamPosKalshi (Nov. 20, ~11:35 AM ET)Earlier Kalshi price
Fernando MendozaRaidersQB25%21% (Nov. 14)
Jonah ColemanBroncosRB19%16% (Nov. 14)
Carnell TateTitansWR15%13% (Nov. 11)
Emmett JohnsonChiefsRB12%9% (Nov. 19)
KC ConcepcionBrownsWR11%10% (Nov. 11)
Denzel BostonBrownsWR10%14% (Nov. 14)
Jordyn TysonSaintsWR8%3% (Nov. 11)
Carson BeckCardinalsQB2%6% (Nov. 11)
Omar Cooper Jr.JetsWR1%5% (Nov. 11)

Current figures are last-trade prices from Kalshi’s market. Nov. 11 prices are from Covers’ Kalshi snapshot that day. Prices move all the time, so check the live market before you trade.

Kalshi · New Users

Claim the Kalshi $55 Bonus

Sign up for Kalshi through Win Daily (referral code DAILYPLAYS applies automatically) and trade $25 to get a $55 bonus.

CLAIM THE $55 KALSHI BONUSKALSHI REVIEW

18+ (21+ where required). New users only. Terms apply. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange; event contract trading involves significant risk. Not available in all jurisdictions; sports contracts are unavailable in some states. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Mendoza’s first start: what happened against Seattle

Mendoza made his first NFL start on Sunday, Nov. 15, against the defending champion Seahawks at Allegiant Stadium. Las Vegas lost 21-13.

  • Passing: 17 of 29 for 143 yards. He was 11 of 13 for 90 yards in the first half and 6 of 16 for 53 yards after the break.
  • Rushing: a 10-yard touchdown on a quarterback draw on the opening drive.
  • Pressure: Seattle sacked him six times, four of them in the second half, and the Raiders went 0-for-7 on third down after halftime.

Mendoza put much of the sack total on himself after the game, and coach Klint Kubiak called the debut good while saying the team has to support him better. Tight end Brock Bowers left in the third quarter with an ankle injury.

The market’s read was clear: a loss with a low passing total did not hurt him. Mendoza’s price rose about four points after the game, because voters tend to reward rookie quarterbacks who start and the rest of the field hasn’t pulled away.

Why Mendoza is the favorite

Mendoza went into the season as the No. 1 overall pick and the reigning Heisman winner, but he opened the year as a backup. Kalshi had him at 12% in Week 1, and he drifted to 5% before Week 9. Then the Raiders traded Kirk Cousins to the Vikings at the deadline and named Mendoza the starter, and his price jumped.

  • Quarterbacks win this award. Four of the last seven winners were quarterbacks (Kyler Murray, Justin Herbert, C.J. Stroud and Jayden Daniels).
  • The field is soft. No rookie has run away with the award, and the receivers split targets on their teams.
  • The preseason favorite fell away. Cardinals running back Jeremiyah Love, who led the market in August, landed on injured reserve and trades near 1%.

The case against him is volume. He has one start, and the next two come against strong defenses.

Games that can move the market next

  • Raiders at Broncos, Sunday, Nov. 22, 4:25 PM ET (CBS): Denver is 7-2, coming off a bye, and had 26 sacks through nine games. It is also Jonah Coleman’s team, so the same game moves both of the top two prices.
  • Raiders at Browns, Sunday, Nov. 29, 8:20 PM ET (NBC): the NFL flexed this game to Sunday Night Football. Cleveland has two contenders, Denzel Boston and KC Concepcion, so a big night from either receiver could pull money away from Mendoza in prime time.

The Raiders are 4-6. The award is a season-long vote, so one game rarely settles it, but a few strong weeks from a rookie quarterback on a national stage can.

The challengers: Coleman, Tate and the Browns receivers

Jonah Coleman (Broncos, RB, 19%). The fourth-round pick became Denver’s lead back. In Week 9 at Carolina he had 17 carries for 57 yards and a touchdown, plus four catches for 31 yards. His weakness with voters is volume: as of early November he had not topped 60 rushing yards in a game. His price leans on Denver’s winning record.

Carnell Tate (Titans, WR, 15%). The No. 4 overall pick had nine catches for 145 yards against Baltimore, but a shoulder injury has cost him games. His price is up two points since Nov. 11 while Boston’s fell.

Denzel Boston and KC Concepcion (Browns, WR, 10% and 11%). Boston was 3% before the season and peaked at 31% in mid-October. The two became the first teammates in NFL history to rank 1-2 in rookie receiving yards through Week 9, but splitting targets caps both totals.

Longer prices. Chiefs running back Emmett Johnson (last trade 12%, up from 9% on Nov. 19) and Saints receiver Jordyn Tyson (8%) have both gained ground. Carson Beck, Arizona’s rookie starter, has faded to 2%.

How to trade the Offensive Rookie of the Year market on Kalshi

Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange, so you are buying and selling event contracts with other traders.

  • Step 1: Open Kalshi and search “Offensive Rookie of the Year.” Pick a player.
  • Step 2: Buy Yes if you think the player’s chance is higher than the price, or No if you think it’s lower.
  • Step 3: Choose how many contracts to buy. At 25¢, $25 buys about 100 Mendoza Yes contracts, which would pay $100 if he wins (before fees).
  • Step 4: Hold until the AP announces the winner, or sell early if the price moves your way after a big game.

Selling early is the main reason to use a market here. If Mendoza plays well in Denver and his price climbs, you can take a profit without waiting until February. If he struggles, you can cut your loss. Prices can also go to zero, so only trade what you can afford to lose.

New users can sign up through our link (referral DAILYPLAYS), trade $25 and get a $55 bonus in trading credits, which can’t be withdrawn as cash. Full details are in our Kalshi promo code review. Kalshi is not available in Nevada, and sports contracts aren’t offered in some states, so check eligibility in your state before you sign up.

CLAIM THE $55 KALSHI BONUS

Can you trade it on Polymarket?

Polymarket’s US app is built around game markets, and we couldn’t confirm a 2026 Offensive Rookie of the Year market there. You can trade Raiders–Broncos and every other NFL game on Polymarket, though. New users who deposit $10 get a $25 trading bonus with code WINDAILY; see our Polymarket promo code review. Polymarket isn’t available in Nevada, and its sports markets aren’t offered in Michigan.

For a side-by-side look at fees and states, see Kalshi vs Polymarket. For the other big award races, see our NFL MVP odds and 2026 Heisman odds.

FAQ

Who is the favorite for NFL Offensive Rookie of the Year in 2026?

Raiders quarterback Fernando Mendoza, at 25% on Kalshi as of about 11:35 AM ET on Nov. 20, 2026. Broncos running back Jonah Coleman (19%) and Titans receiver Carnell Tate (15%) are next.

How did Fernando Mendoza play in his first NFL start?

He completed 17 of 29 passes for 143 yards, ran for a 10-yard touchdown on the opening drive and was sacked six times in a 21-13 loss to Seattle on Nov. 15. His Kalshi price still rose afterward.

When is Fernando Mendoza’s next start?

Sunday, Nov. 22, 2026, at the Denver Broncos. Kickoff is 4:25 PM ET on CBS. The Raiders then play at Cleveland on Sunday Night Football on Nov. 29.

How does the Kalshi Offensive Rookie of the Year market pay out?

Each Yes contract pays $1 if your player wins the AP award and $0 if he doesn’t. You can also sell your contracts before the winner is announced.

Who won Offensive Rookie of the Year last season?

Panthers receiver Tetairoa McMillan won the award for the 2025 season, and Kalshi’s market settled on him in February 2026.

More prediction market guides

Win Daily may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this page, at no cost to you. Offers, availability and terms are set by the partner and can change; confirm terms in the app before you play or trade. 18+ (21+ where required). New users only. Terms apply. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange; event contract trading involves significant risk. Not available in all jurisdictions; sports contracts are unavailable in some states. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Play responsibly; call/text 1-800-MY-RESET for help.

Claim your bonus before you play

New-player offers from the prediction market apps available in your state.

21+ (18+ where permitted) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET.