2026 Heisman Odds on Kalshi and Polymarket: Smith, Mensah or Carr?

2026 Heisman Odds on Kalshi and Polymarket: Smith, Mensah or Carr?

Updated November 12, 2026

Kalshi · New Users

Kalshi: Trade $25, Get a $55 Bonus

Sign up for Kalshi through Win Daily (referral code DAILYPLAYS applies automatically) and trade $25 to get a $55 bonus.

CLAIM THE $55 KALSHI BONUSKALSHI REVIEW

18+ (21+ where required). New users only. Terms apply. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange; event contract trading involves significant risk. Not available in all jurisdictions; sports contracts are unavailable in some states. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Ohio State wide receiver Jeremiah Smith is the slim favorite in the 2026 Heisman Trophy markets, priced around 31%, with Miami quarterback Darian Mensah (about 27% to 28%) and Notre Dame quarterback CJ Carr (about 17%) close behind. Those are Kalshi and Polymarket prices from early Thursday afternoon, Nov. 12, and they have swung hard over the last three weeks.

This page tracks what the prediction markets say, why the race tightened, the games that can move it this weekend, and how to trade the Heisman market yourself.

2026 Heisman odds right now

Prices as of about 1:10 PM ET, Nov. 12, 2026. A price of 31 cents means the market puts that player's chance at roughly 31%.

  • Jeremiah Smith (Ohio State, WR): Kalshi 31%, Polymarket 31%
  • Darian Mensah (Miami, QB): Kalshi 28%, Polymarket 27%
  • CJ Carr (Notre Dame, QB): Kalshi 17%, Polymarket 17%
  • Drew Mestemaker (Oklahoma State, QB): Kalshi about 6%, Polymarket about 5%
  • Gunner Stockton (Georgia, QB): Kalshi about 6%, Polymarket about 5%
  • Devon Dampier (Utah, QB): Kalshi about 5%

Kalshi figures are last-trade prices from its Heisman Trophy winner market. Polymarket's figures are from its "NCAA Football: 2026 Heisman Award Winner" market. Prices change by the minute, so check the live market before you trade.

How the race got this close

Three weeks ago this looked like Smith's trophy. On Oct. 21, Kalshi had him at 41%, with Mensah at 23% and Ole Miss quarterback Trinidad Chambliss at 9%. Carr was a 4% long shot.

Then Ohio State's season wobbled. The Buckeyes lost three straight regular-season games for the first time since 2011, the latest to Oregon, and fell to No. 20. Starting quarterback Julian Sayin is out injured and may not return until mid-December, which leaves Smith catching passes from backup Luke Fahey. Smith still produced 7 catches for 133 yards and a touchdown against Oregon, but a receiver on a three-loss team is a harder sell to voters.

Mensah climbed on numbers. He led FBS in QBR (89.4) in late October with 18 touchdowns and one interception, and Covers had him over 2,700 yards with 28 touchdowns and two interceptions by Nov. 8. His top receiver, Malachi Toney, has been out with an ankle injury.

Carr made the biggest jump. In Notre Dame's 31-24 win over Miami on Nov. 7, he went 29-of-40 for 319 yards and three touchdowns, outplaying Mensah head to head. Kalshi's Nov. 11 update says Carr peaked at 36% after that game before settling back. Notre Dame sits No. 5 in the latest College Football Playoff rankings, Miami No. 7.

Kalshi · New Users

Claim the Kalshi $55 Bonus

Sign up for Kalshi through Win Daily (referral code DAILYPLAYS applies automatically) and trade $25 to get a $55 bonus.

CLAIM THE $55 KALSHI BONUSKALSHI REVIEW

18+ (21+ where required). New users only. Terms apply. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange; event contract trading involves significant risk. Not available in all jurisdictions; sports contracts are unavailable in some states. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Games that can move the Heisman market this week

All four leading candidates play Saturday, Nov. 14:

  • Jeremiah Smith: Northwestern (6-3) at Ohio State (6-3). Remaining after that: Nebraska and Michigan.
  • Darian Mensah: Duke (7-2) at Miami (8-1) on ABC. Miami has two more ACC games after this and a possible ACC title game.
  • CJ Carr: Boston College (4-5) at Notre Dame (8-1) on NBC. Then SMU and Syracuse.
  • Drew Mestemaker: No. 12 Texas Tech at No. 25 Oklahoma State on ESPN, the biggest test of his season (2,962 passing yards, 32 total TDs before this week).
  • Devon Dampier: undefeated Utah, No. 2 in the CFP rankings, plays at Arizona.

Big stat lines in blowouts tend to nudge prices a few points. A loss by a contender's team usually moves them more.

Key dates

  • Heisman finalists announced: Monday, Dec. 7, 2026.
  • Heisman Trophy ceremony: Saturday, Dec. 12, 2026, in New York.
  • Polymarket's market is set to end Dec. 27, and Kalshi's runs to Jan. 1, 2027, so both settle on the official winner.

How to read Heisman prices

Prediction markets let you buy "Yes" or "No" shares on an outcome. If you buy Smith "Yes" at 31 cents and he wins, each share settles at $1. If he doesn't, it settles at $0. You can also sell before the ceremony if the price moves your way, which is how many traders use award markets: buy a candidate before a big game and sell after a strong performance.

Things to keep in mind:

  • The favorite is not a lock. At about 31%, the market thinks Smith loses more than two times in three.
  • Voters, not stats, decide. The trophy is a vote, and quarterbacks have won most Heismans this century. That history is part of why Mensah and Carr trade so close to Smith.
  • Thin markets move fast. Lower-priced candidates have little volume, so one large order can shift the price.

For a side-by-side look at the two apps, read Kalshi vs Polymarket, or browse our best prediction market apps.

How to trade the Heisman market on Kalshi

Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange with a Heisman winner market listing about 50 candidates. Sign up with our link, trade $25, and you get a $55 bonus in trading credits (non-withdrawable). Sports contracts are not available in every state, so check eligibility in your state. Full details are in our Kalshi promo code review.

  • Step 1: Tap the button below and create your Kalshi account.
  • Step 2: Verify your identity and fund your account.
  • Step 3: Search "Heisman" and pick a candidate.
  • Step 4: Buy Yes or No at the current price, or set a limit order.

CLAIM THE $55 KALSHI BONUS

How to trade the Heisman market on Polymarket

Polymarket's U.S. app lists the 2026 Heisman winner market too. New users who deposit $10 get a $25 trading bonus with code WINDAILY. Polymarket isn't available in Nevada, and its sports markets aren't offered in Michigan. See our Polymarket promo code review for the steps. Trade only what you can afford to lose; no market outcome is guaranteed.

FAQ

Who is the favorite to win the 2026 Heisman Trophy?

Ohio State WR Jeremiah Smith, at about 31% on Kalshi and Polymarket as of Nov. 12. Miami QB Darian Mensah and Notre Dame QB CJ Carr are the next two.

When is the 2026 Heisman Trophy ceremony?

Saturday, Dec. 12, 2026, in New York. The finalists are announced Monday, Dec. 7.

Why did CJ Carr's Heisman odds jump?

He threw for 319 yards and three touchdowns in Notre Dame's 31-24 win over Miami on Nov. 7, beating Mensah head to head. His Kalshi price rose from 4% in late October to the high teens.

Can you trade Heisman odds on Kalshi?

Yes. Kalshi lists a Heisman Trophy winner market, but sports contracts are restricted in some states, so check eligibility where you live.

Do Heisman markets pay out before the ceremony?

No. Contracts settle after the official winner is announced, but you can sell your position at the market price any time before then.

More prediction market guides

Win Daily may earn a commission when you sign up through links on this page, at no cost to you. Offers, availability and terms are set by the partner and can change; confirm terms in the app before you play or trade. 18+ (21+ where required). New users only. Terms apply. Kalshi is a CFTC-regulated exchange; event contract trading involves significant risk. Not available in all jurisdictions; sports contracts are unavailable in some states. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER. Play responsibly; call/text 1-800-MY-RESET for help.

Claim your bonus before you play

New-player offers from the prediction market apps available in your state.

21+ (18+ where permitted) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER or 1-800-MY-RESET.