Change Your Game & Change Your Life
WD PoweredAI · Week 11 start/sit

Geno Smith vs J.J. McCarthy: Who Should You Start in Week 11?

Updated November 22, 2026 1:49 AM ET · Projections from the WinDaily model · Analysis by WD PoweredAI

QB · Jets @ ChargersQB · Giants vs JaguarsPPR · Half · Standard
The call (PPR)
Start Geno Smith
Coin flip · sit J.J. McCarthy

Geno Smith edges McCarthy by volume and passing upside despite similar point projections.

PPR: Geno Smith (+0.5)Half PPR: Geno Smith (+0.5)Standard: Geno Smith (+0.5)

Side-by-side

Geno SmithJ.J. McCarthy
Position · TeamQB · JetsQB · Giants
Matchup@ Chargers · Sun 4:05 PM ETvs Jaguars · Sun 4:25 PM ET
PPR projection13.5 pts13 pts
Half-PPR projection13.5 pts13 pts
Standard projection13.5 pts13 pts
Injury statusNo designationNo designation
Role / usage29.2 att/g21.4 att/g
Projected Pass yds210194
Projected Pass TD1.21
Projected Rush yds416
Projected Rush/rec TD0.050.14

WD PoweredAI breakdown

Both project within 0.4 points, but Smith's 29.2 attempts per game versus McCarthy's 21.4 creates a higher ceiling. Smith's projection leans on 209 passing yards and 1.2 TD passes; McCarthy needs his 1.0 TD pass plus rushing production (16 yards, 0.14 rushing/receiving TD) to hit similar value. Smith gets more chances to score from the pocket.

The Jets face a Chargers pass defense ranked middle-of-the-pack with no major injury concerns for either offense. The Giants draw Jacksonville, a weaker secondary that could elevate McCarthy's upside. Game environments are comparable in pace and scoring potential. Smith's higher usage volume remains the deciding factor in a close matchup.

Smith's floor is safer because of volume; a game-managing day still yields 12-13 points. McCarthy's ceiling is competitive if he executes in the red zone, but his floor dips faster without rushing production. For PPR rosters needing floor, Smith's reliable attempt rate wins. For ceiling-chasing lineups, McCarthy's rushing floor (16 yards) and Jaguars matchup offer appeal.

Does PPR or standard scoring change the call?

PPR doesn't materially shift this call—neither is catch-dependent. Standard scoring slightly favors Smith by reducing McCarthy's rushing TD equity, though both remain viable in any format.

What to watch before kickoff

Monitor Smith's shoulder status and any Jets-Chargers game script changes; McCarthy's Giants targets and red-zone touches before Sunday.

How we project: player stats and usage, opponent defense, game environment from the betting line and, where sportsbooks post them, player props. Projections, not guarantees. See all NFL fantasy projections and player prop trends.

More Week 11 start/sit calls

Compare other players

🏈Your start/sit call shows up hereAdd two to four players on the left and hit “Who should I start?”

Projections from the WinDaily model: stats and usage, opponent defense, game environment from the betting line, injury status and sportsbook player props. Projections, not guarantees.

Play your starters: fantasy app offers

18+ (21+ in some states) and present in an eligible state. Terms apply. Gambling problem? Call 1-800-GAMBLER.

Turn these projections into lineups

Build up to 150 DraftKings or FanDuel lineups from these numbers with our free NFL DFS lineup optimizer. Stacks, exposure caps and CSV export included, no signup.

Open the free NFL optimizer
Fantasy app promo codes: PrizePicks promo code · Underdog promo code · Sleeper promo code · DraftKings Pick6 promo code · Betr Picks promo code. New-player offers checked November 2026; availability depends on your state.